RISK AND SAFETY LEVEL ASSESSMENT OF SHIP — BRIDGE COLLISION

10.33815/2313-4763.2020.1.22.011-021

Keywords: ship-bridge collision, accident, safety levels, identifying risks, prevent hazards, virtual navigation aids, technologies

Abstract

Bridges which located on maritime and inland waterways are defenseless object of infrastructure. One of their  main  features  is  the  restriction  of  navigation  channels,  both  vertically  and  horizontally,  while navigation conditions are often complicated by unpredictable currents and whirlpools. A great threat to people and vehicles located on or near the structure occurred in case of collision with ships and the destruction of bridges. Also, the consequences of such incident are large financial costs, where the cost of the bridge is usually much more than the cost of the vessel itself. The article addresses the issue of types, factors, causes and consequences of ship-bridge collision accidents. In spite of the modern level of development in the maritime industry such accidents occur annually, thus this problem is relevant nowadays. It is necessary to take measures to increase the safety of navigation in appropriate zones. The article presents the procedure for assessing the level of safety and the stages of identifying risks by determining the probability of a collision with bridge spans, supports and other structures, also identifying the most defenseless places, as well as the possible consequences of such damage (ship, cities, environment). In addition, the paper considered the methods of protection the bridge from collision and methods for reducing navigational risk. The results of the research are developing recommendations for avoiding possible dangers, mitigation  of  consequences  and  reducing  risks  of  vessel-bridge  collision.  It  is  proposed  to  form  an «intellectual» zone in the navigable water area under bridge to minimize the risks and consequences of an emergency. As a basic concept, it is recommended to use foreign and domestic experience in implementing the e-navigation strategy in the coastal zone and in the operational VTS areas.

The article describes the implementation of modern marine technologies, such as virtual navigation aids and technologies of additional reality, which will significantly improve monitoring of the environment. Therefore, this introduction will reduce the risk of emergency. Ensuring the full spectrum of available methods is necessary to determine risk and protect bridges from accidents. Such approach will allow not only assess risk of ship collision with bridge, but also to introduce additional active control elements during navigation in dangerous zones.

References

1. Stolknoveniya s mostami. Elektronny`j morskoj zhurnal. URL:http://www.morvesti.ru/themes/1693/71176/
2. Formal Safety Assessment (IMO). Official website of International Maritime Organization.URL:http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Safety/SafetyTopics/Pages/FormalSafetyAs sessment.aspx
3. 1991 Aashto Annual Meeting Proceedings: Selected Committee Meeting Papers Presented at the Seventy-Seventh Annual Meeting of the American Association – May 1, 1992. URL: https://policy.transportation.org/aashto-annual-meeting/
4. Auslegungen zu DIN 1055-9 «Einwirkungen auf Tragwerke – Teil 9: Außergewöhnliche Einwirkungen». Stand der Auslegungen: Oktober 2007. URL: https://www.din.de/resource/blob/77472/af0b5a373f53d9d56c29e54672738a63/auslegungen-zu- din-1055-9-data.pdf
5. EN 1991-1-1 (2002) (English): Eurocode 1: Actions on structures - Part 1-1: General actions - Densities, self-weight, imposed loads for buildings. Authority: The European Union Per Regulation 305/2011, Directive 98/34/EC, Directive 2004/18/EC. URL: https://www.phd.eng.br/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/en.1991.1.1.2002.pdf
6. Ship Collision Analysis. Edited by Henrik Gluver and Dan Olsen (Larsen 1993). URL:https://books.google.com.ua/books?id=FxwuDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT176&dq=Larsen+1993+ Collision&hl=ru&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiS3X9yffpAhWaAxAIHRNvBJEQ6AEIMDAB#v=one page&q=Larsen%201993%20Collision&f=false
7. Motrich V. N. (2017). Stolknoveniya sudov i ix preduprezhdenie. Novy`j vzglyad. Izdatel`stvo: BHV. 349 s.
8. Provodka sudov v mestax raspolozheniya mostov. Elektronny`j morskoj zhurnal. URL: http://studepedia.org/index.php?vol=1&post=78450
9. Guide Specifications and Commentary for Vessel Collision Design of Highway Bridges Second Edition 2009. URL: https://books.google.com.ua/books?id=V3jQalaH47UC&printsec=frontcover&hl=ru&source=gb s_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false
10. Larsen O.D. Ship Collision with Bridges: The Interaction between Vessel Traffic and Bridge Structures. IABSE, 1993. 131 p.
11. Risk assessment of bridge collision – using Monte Carlo Simulation. URL:
https://www.sspa.se/safety-security-and-risk/risk-assessment-bridge-collision-using-monte- carlo-simulation
12. Zajkov V. I., Kolosov M. A. Povy`shenie bezopasnosti pri dvizhenii sudov pod mostami. URL: http://rostransport.com/transportrf/archiv/text.php?ID=&pdf=10531
13. Knott M., Winters M. Ship and barge collision with bridge over navigable waterway. Electronic Marine Journal. URL : https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/1783/
5fb7e9b809f641e4769fe8292a53f7903d6a.pdf
14. DAI Tong-yu, NIE Wu, LIU Ying - jie , WANG Li-ping (2002). Statistical Analysis of Ship Collisions with Bridges in China Waterway. Journal of Marine Science and Application, Vol. 1, No. 2. P. 28.
15. Holger Svensson. (2009). Protection of bridge piers against ship collision. Steel
Construction 2. Articles DOI: 10.1002/stco.200910004. P. 21–32.
16. DBN V.2.3-XX:201X. Derzhavni budivel`ni normy` Ukrayiny`, mosty` ta truby`, obstezhennya ta vy`probuvannya. Ministerstvo regional`nogo rozvy`tku budivny`cztva ta zhy`tlovo-komunal`nogo gospodarstva Ukrayiny` 201X. 20 s. (Informaciya ta dokumentaciya).
17. Danielsen K. Collision with the Great Belt West Bridge 3 March 2005. The joint Bahamas Maritime Authorities & Danish Division for Investigation of Maritime Accidents report. URL: https://www.bahamasmaritime.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/KAREN-DANIELSON- FINAL-REPORT-Mar-2005.pdf
18. Voytenko M. Lena J collided with bridge in Colborne, Canada. Electronic Marine News Journal FleetMon. URL : https://www.fleetmon.com/maritime-news/2015/9583/lena-j- collided-bridge-colborne-canada/
19. Voytenko M. OLDENDORFF cargo ship collided with bridge, thousands cut off water, Japan. Electronic Maritime Bulletin. URL : http://www.maritimebulletin.net/2018/10/22/oldendorff-cargo-ship-collided-with-bridge- thousands-cut-off-water-japan/
20. Cheromcha K. Cargo Ship Led by Drunk Russian Captain Crashes into Major South Korea Bridge. Electronic Marine News Journal The Drive. URL : https://www.thedrive.com/news/26693/cargo-ship-led-by-drunk-russian-captain-crashes-into- major-south-korea-bridge
21. Golikov A.O., Olijny`k Yu.O. (2020). Aktual`nist` vy`kory`stannya virtual`ny`x ZNO na vnutrishnix vodny`x shlyaxax Ukrayiny`. Suchasni informacijni ta inovacijni texnologiyi na transporti MINTT-2020: zb. tez dop. mizhnar. nauk.-prakt. konf., m. Xerson, 27-29 trav. 2020r. Xerson.
22. E-navigation Portal (IALA). Official website of The International Association of Marine Aids to Navigation and Lighthouse Authorities. URL: https://www.iala- aism.org/technical/e-navigation/
23. Boshkov I. I., Krutikova A. A. (2018). Sistemy` dopolnitel`noj real`nosti dlya morskoj navigacii. Texnicheskie nauki. № 8. S. 6–8. URL : https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/sistemy- dopolnennoy-realnosti-dlya-morskoy-navigatsii/viewer
Published
2020-10-05